New York Knicks owner lawsuit against NBA commissioner

• New York Knicks owner James Dolan has resigned from the NBA board
• Dolan has filed a lawsuit against the Toronto Raptors that includes allegations questioning the NBA Commissioner Adam Silver
• The memo addressed to Silver and copied to the league’s other 29 owners conveyed Dolan’s conclusion that the NBA neither requires nor desires his input

In a surprising move, New York Knicks owner James Dolan has resigned from his roles on the NBA Board of Governors’ influential advisory/finance and media committees. This decision follows an unconventional lawsuit filed against the Toronto Raptors, where Dolan challenges the impartiality of NBA commissioner Adam Silver. Details of Dolan’s departure from these committees were outlined in a memo obtained by ESPN.

Dated July, the memo addressed to Silver and copied to the league’s other 29 owners conveyed Dolan’s conclusion that the NBA neither requires nor desires his input. Although he retained voting authority for the Knicks, Dolan stated his intention to discontinue attending board of governor meetings. Instead, Knicks General Counsel Jamaal Lesane would represent the team at these gatherings—a transition that sources confirm has already occurred.

Expressing a desire for equitable treatment of the Knicks, Dolan mentioned his busy schedule with duties at MSG family of companies, stating, “I need to apply my time where I can be most productive.”

READ; NBA in-season tournament: Los Angeles Lakers cruise through

New York Knicks owner James Dolan has resigned from his positions on the NBA Board of Governors after filing a lawsuit against the Toronto Raptors and NBA Commissioner Adam Silver. | PHOTO: CBC |

This decision comes on the heels of Dolan’s dissent in two recent votes that had otherwise been unanimous. He voted against Michael Jordan’s sale of the Charlotte Hornets and opposed the WNBA expansion to San Francisco. Sources suggest Dolan’s discontent has been mounting over the years, particularly regarding the NBA’s revenue-sharing system. The Knicks owner is reportedly dissatisfied with the obligation for high-market teams to share their substantially larger revenue with smaller-market counterparts.

Simultaneously, the Knicks find themselves embroiled in a legal dispute with the Raptors, as outlined in a court filing on Monday. The Knicks are alleging the theft of thousands of confidential files and seeking over $10 million in damages. Responding to the Raptors’ motion to dismiss the initial complaint and have Commissioner Silver arbitrate the dispute, the Knicks argue against Silver’s involvement due to his close ties with Raptors governor Larry Tanenbaum. The filing suggests that Tanenbaum’s role as the chairman of the NBA’s board of governors creates a conflict of interest, as he wields influence over Silver’s employment and salary. This alleged bias, the Knicks claim, would compromise the arbitration process.

READ: New York Knicks to lose 2025 second-round pick

At the heart of the Knicks’ legal action is a practice common among coaching staff—bringing files and notes related to previous programs when changing teams. This lawsuit, coupled with Dolan’s withdrawal from pivotal NBA committees, introduces complexities to the league’s dynamics, raising questions about the interplay between ownership, governance, and legal disputes in professional basketball.

Continuing the narrative, the Knicks’ legal maneuvering has injected an air of uncertainty into the league, prompting discussions about the boundaries between team ownership, legal battles, and the role of the commissioner in dispute resolution. Dolan’s decision to distance himself from NBA committees, while still retaining voting rights for the Knicks, underscores a shifting landscape where team owners grapple with the delicate balance between individual interests and the greater good of the league.

The Raptors, on their part, remain steadfast in their desire to have Commissioner Silver arbitrate the dispute, dismissing the Knicks’ claims of bias due to Tanenbaum’s role. The legal proceedings are poised to unveil the intricacies of professional sports governance, exploring the limits of commissioner authority and the safeguards in place to ensure fairness and transparency.

As the NBA season unfolds, the off-court drama between the Knicks and Raptors adds an unexpected layer to the usual on-court spectacle. The league, no stranger to controversies and legal battles, will navigate uncharted territory as it addresses the nuanced issues raised by Dolan’s resignation from key committees and the ensuing legal clash between two prominent franchises.